قالب وردپرس درنا توس
Home https://server7.kproxy.com/servlet/redirect.srv/sruj/smyrwpoii/p2/ Entertainment https://server7.kproxy.com/servlet/redirect.srv/sruj/smyrwpoii/p2/ True story behind green book

True story behind green book



In a non-controversial Oscar season, Green Book represented Green Head headlines as one of the most divisive Best Picture nominees. It is a sensitive film about the healing of racial wounds that has not been seen but two related controversies – only when star Viggo Mortensen dropped the nombom during a Q&A, and then, co-author Nick Vallelonga's Islamophobic tweets appeared.

These controversies are symptomatic of the film itself, a based-on-a-true story white savior road trip film that uses fried chicken as its search motif. While Mortensen and his co-stars Mahershala Ali both turn into amazing performances, casting is basically the only thing that the film becomes real. In handling everything from the biography of one of the men in the heart of the movie to the character of the American racism, [GreenPaper stumbled.

The film is a classic road story that tells the story of Bronx bouncer Tony Vallelonga (Mortensen), who in 1

962 found work as a service as a driver and bodyguard for Dr. Donald Shirley (Ali), a queer black composer who makes a dangerous concert tour through the south. (Under his nickname, Tony Lip, the one-time bouncer will continue to be a successful actor, the most well-known player Lupertazzi's family chief Carmine on the Sopranoes. ) In the movie, Tony teaches the classy classical musician to release Doc As Tony calls him, his driver again learns to be less racist. It is saccharin and predictable for the core, and it took home three Golden Globes, including Best Picture. It's up to five more trophies – including Best Photo, Best Actor for Mortensen, Best Supporting Actor for Ali and Best Original Play – Sunday.

  image "title =" image "class =" lazyimage lazyload "data-src =" https://hips.hearstapps.com/hmg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/images/don-shirley-1550950191.jpg </span><span class= Getty Images Alfred Eisenstaedt

But the film's first sin is just in its name. It takes its title from N Egro Travelers & # 39; Green Book and yet this important piece of American history gives little screen time or analysis. The Green Book was an annual guide published by Victor Hugo Green and his family between 1936 and 1966, and listed hotels, petrol stations and restaurants around the country that would be hospitable to black visitors. Thousands of copies were sold each year to black travelers, well aware that even the most innocent road trips left them swapping racist humiliations from denial of service to direct violence. In the movie Tony flips through the book a couple of times before landing Doc in some rather seedy motels, some experts have pointed out to be inaccurate, as the real Green Book often guided travelers to higher places. The film also suggests that the advice offered in Green's guide would only be needed in the South, as the book actually began as a pamphlet suggesting hospitable businesses in the author's original New York.

It is not the film's only misleading depiction of racism. In a scene, a southern lawyer pulls over Tony and Doc's car at night to drive the couple out of town and warn that they were in a "sundown town" community that did not allow black people to stay after night. "Sundown cities were incredibly rare in the south" expert James W. Loewen told Politifact . " White southerners believed sunsets were stupid – who would be the girl?"

There has also been debate about the accuracy of the film's portrayal of the two men. Both are portrayed as broad stereotypes; Tony is the Bronx hard guy with a disposition against occasional violence and often seen wearing underwear. Doc is absurdly preoccupied, obstructed by rudeness and quick to offer grammatical corrections. While Tiger's spouse son Nick Vallelonga wrote together Green Book – and could probably have vetoed, says the scene where his father folds a whole pizza in half and queues down – Dr. Shirley's family had no way of informing their relatives' portrayal; they were not heard at all and condemned the film as inaccurate.

  image "title =" image "class =" lazyimage lazyload "data-src =" https://hips.hearstapps.com/hmg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/images/green-book-1550950270.jpg ? crop = 1xw: 1xh; center, top & resize = 480: * "/> </picture></div>
</p></div>
<p>
			<span class= Universal Pictures

Shirley's surviving brother, Dr. Maurice Shirley, called the movie a" symphony of lies "in an interview with Shadow and Act The film depicts Dr. Shirley, who resembles his former driver died in 2013 as a man whose education and refinement puts him at odds with the black community, indifferent to black music and unpleasant around other African Americans. "I'm not accepted by my own people because I'm not like them," Doc said at a time in film. His character is extremely isolated, and the only mention his family receives is a reference to a single stranger.

But in 1962 Shirley actually had three living brothers, a d his family says he during the tour that was portrayed Right in the movie, had regular contact with them. Not only that, but the family insists that Shirley was deeply embedded in the black community. He participated in the Civil Rights Movement and was friends with Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., who was the occasional patient of Shirley's brother, the doctor Dr. Edwin Shirley. He was friends with Duke Ellington and Sarah Vaughan, and a participant of Dr. King's March at Selma.

  Fifth Season of Sopranos DVD Launch Party "title =" Fifth Season of Sopranos DVD Launch Party "class =" Lazyimage Lazyload "data-src =" https://hips.hearstapps.com/hmg-prod.s3 .amazonaws .com / images / actor-tony-lip-self-present-de-soprano-the-complete fifth-news-photo-53029665-1550949366.jpg crop = 1.00xw :? 0.695xh; 0.0708xh & resize = 480: * 19659017] The real life Tony Vallelonga, both he and Shirley died in 2013. </figcaption>
<p>
			<span class= Getty Images Paul Hawthorne

"The character so beautifully played by Mahershala Ali, was simply not Uncle Donald I knew, "Edwin Shirley wrote in an email to Time ." They made a commercially successful, popular movie, but in the process distorted and diminished the life of one of those Two main characters: They have impaired the integrity of Donald Shirley's life with events and innuendo that just contradict the man I knew. "

One of the film's greatest inaccuracies lies in its embellishment of racism by the individual ignorance of Underexposed white Americans, rather than a systematic structure of targeted inequality. Here is race hat in white Northerner's peccadillo, which quickly flushes away in the light of black genius. During the film, Tony evolves from being a bigot, who initially throws out water glasses simply because black handlers drank from them to be a man who-spoiler alert! -Invites Doc for his home for Christmas dinner. He found it in itself to recognize mankind by a man who was clearly his professional and intellectual superior, but we never discover what he now thinks of the craftsmen.

And in a film that pursues a smooth message of racial harmony, one of its most enchanted undercurrents is the suggestion that Shirley's refinements make him somehow alien to the black community. In fact, each of Shirley's three brothers were also doctors, and the 1960s America was home to a thriving black upper class filled with people who spoke multiple languages ​​and loved classical music. Although Dr. Shirley probably was more talented than anyone other than some of his contemporaries, insisted the film's claim that a black man who appreciates tailor-made suits speaks Italian and is fond of French opera was somewhat akin to a UFO is the most disgusting suggestion of all.


Source link